Accepting Returns

If for any reason you aren't satisfied, you can return any non-engraved item in its original condition for a refund or exchange. If you have any questions about our return procedure, please don't hesitate to contact us.

Returning Your Order

To return a jewelry item to Benjy's Jewelers., follow our three step process:

1. Place all the original packaging in the box, including the appraisal if a Diamond. If an Exchange an instructions for exchange. You do not need a return authorization number. For security reasons, do not write Jewelry anywhere on the outside of the box.

    

2. On your invoice, if the price of the item you're returning is listed as:
    
   • Less than $500: You can ship it via any carrier. Be sure to ship your item fully insured, and request a return receipt for confirmation that your shipment has reached its destination.*
   • More than $500: Ship your package via US Postal Service Registered Mail™ or UPS® insured for the total value of the contents, and request a return receipt for confirmation that your shipment has reached Benjy's Jewelers..* (FedEx®  will not insure merchandise over $500.)

    

3. ship your returns to the following address:

   Benjy's Jewelers
   Attn: Returns
   230 County St,New Bedford,
   MA - 02740

   And Exchange

   Benjy's Jewelers
   Attn: Exchange
   230 County St,New Bedford,
   MA - 02740

    

Once your return is received, it will be reviewed by our Quality Assurance department. You will receive credit back to the same credit card which was charged to or exchange within seven business days.

Any  improperly packaged, or non-insured packages will be returned to sender. Items that show signs of wear or have been resized (by a jeweler other than Benjy's Jewelers.), engraved, altered, special ordered items or damaged in any way cannot be accepted for return.

* Benjy's Jewelers. will not be responsible for loss or damage of return shipments.